HMRC rules for recognised transfers
Which drawdown funds can be transferred?
Any crystallised pension already in drawdown can be transferred including:
- drawdown pension fund
- flexi-access drawdown fund
- dependant’s drawdown pension fund
- dependant’s flexi-access drawdown fund
- nominee’s flexi-access drawdown fund
- successor’s flexi-access drawdown fund
However, for a drawdown-to-drawdown transfer to be recognised, the following conditions must be met:
- All sums and assets in the drawdown fund must be transferred; partial transfers are not recognised.
- The receiving scheme must create a new arrangement for the transferred funds which holds no other sums or assets.
- The new arrangement must provide the same type of drawdown (for example, flexi-access drawdown to flexi-access drawdown).
- Scheme administrators must exchange details of benefit crystallisation events and allowances used.
Notional or blink of an eye drawdown plans
It is possible to transfer funds that are already in drawdown to another provider, subject to the relevant conditions applying to the transfer. In the case of beneficiary drawdown, for example, a beneficiary drawdown plan can be transferred to another provider, but the beneficiary must first be in beneficiary drawdown with the ceding scheme before a beneficiary drawdown-to-beneficiary drawdown transfer can take place.
Historically, some providers used an approach commonly referred to as ‘notional’ or ‘blink of an eye’ drawdown. This involved treating funds as having been designated to drawdown immediately before they were transferred to another provider as a drawdown-to-drawdown transfer.
HMRC has clarified the requirements for an effective designation to drawdown. Simply informing the scheme that funds are being designated is not sufficient. For a designation to take effect, the scheme must be capable of making a payment of income withdrawal from the designated funds. An income payment does not actually have to be made by the designating scheme, but it must be possible for the scheme to make one.
Therefore, where an arrangement cannot provide an income withdrawal and the funds must be transferred to another arrangement before income can be paid, there has not been an effective designation to drawdown. The funds cannot simply be treated as being in drawdown on a ‘notional’ or ‘blink of an eye’ basis to facilitate a subsequent drawdown-to-drawdown transfer
HMRC Pension Tax Manual - PTM062701: Member benefits: pensions: drawdown pension rules applying from 6 April 2015
Tax Treatment and practical implications
A recognised transfer avoids unauthorised payment tax charges. However, failure to meet HMRC conditions—such as paying a partial transfer—will result an unauthorised payments tax charge of up to 55%. Advisers should ensure compliance and keep an audit trail, especially where statutory overrides or block transfers are involved.
HMRC Tax manual - PTM131000: Unauthorised payments: essential principles