Mortgage protection for unmarried couples
People understand that mortgage loans are taken out over long periods of time and are usually the biggest debts they will ever have.
People also understand that mortgages are secured against the property and the loan does need to be paid back, so a protection policy that allows each mortgagor the ability to repay the mortgage in the event of death or serious illness is an easy concept to understand.
However, the design of a mortgage protection solution for an unmarried couple requires a little bit of extra thought because it’s not quite as straightforward as you might imagine.
Designing the solution
Let’s consider a life assurance mortgage protection solution. How do we achieve a good customer outcome by way of what needs to happen if a claim is ever registered? A good customer outcome for a jointly held mortgage might look like this…
If one partner dies during the mortgage term; the surviving partner needs to be in a position to pay off the mortgage so they can keep the home.
The default protection solution for joint mortgage borrowers is typically a joint life first death life assurance policy. It would typically be ‘decreasing’ to run in line with a capital and interest mortgage, or, ‘level’ to run in line with interest only mortgages.
The term should match the term of the mortgage and the sum assured should match the amount of the mortgage balance. But for unmarried couples, there is a sting in the tail with this type of solution. The problem concerns tax!
The taxable estate
Let’s say an unmarried couple take out a joint life mortgage protection policy for a property they owned together. At some point in the future, one of them dies so the other makes a claim on the policy.
When the claim is paid, the surviving partner would receive the full sum assured. This would put them in a position to fully repay the mortgage debt and sounds like a good customer outcome. But the problem could potentially arise when looking at the estate of the deceased.
The probate process requires disclosure of all assets held by the deceased. This is to ascertain whether there will be any inheritance tax to pay or not. Included within the assets of the deceased will be the property.
The value of the deceased’s share of the property will form part of their taxable estate (even though it actually passes to their partner). But another asset which will form part of their taxable estate will be the protection policy.
For an unmarried couple; HMRC will count half of the joint life policy sum assured in the estate of the deceased. This is again, a paper exercise because the reality is the survivor would have already claimed the full sum assured. The funds from the life assurance policy will never actually enter the estate of the deceased but they could be taxed.
By including half of the sum assured (which could be considerable), within the estate of the deceased, this could increase or even give rise to an inheritance tax charge.
So it’s quite likely that if this scenario ever arose, the family of the deceased could look to take legal action against the adviser who first recommended what was, a very simple and straightforward protection solution.
What’s the solution then?
Advisers can’t possibly predict the future wealth of their client’s estates, or whether they ever actually make a claim on an insurance policy. And there's no way of knowing whether the recommendation of a joint life protection solution to an unmarried couple is ever going to cause a problem. But we need to make sure these types of scenarios are taken into account during the advice and recommendation process.
For unmarried couples, the best solution would be for each partner to take out individual protection cover and these policies would need to be written into trust. Beneficiaries can be nominated and, for this type of scenario, the beneficiary would be the other partner.
An alternative solution would be to write the individual protection cover on a life of another basis. But this is a lot less flexible. For example, what would happen if the couple split up or wish to change their beneficiary at some point in the future?
With a trust, beneficiaries can easily be changed if there's a need to change them. This can be accommodated in a Letter of Wishes, which is usually a good idea to review from time to time because amendments and updates can be made where necessary.
So, a good outcome for an unmarried couple would be to make sure that should either of them die during the mortgage term, the other partner is in a position to repay the mortgage debt. But to also make sure we don’t add to, or increase, any possible inheritance tax on the estate of the deceased.
More articles you might like
Let’s talk about Trusts: what are gifted and retained benefits?
Gregor Sked, Senior Intermediary Development and Technical Manager at Royal London, discusses Trusts and explains what retained and gifted benefits are.
We’re all going on a Summer Holiday
Shelley Read, Senior Intermediary Development and Technical Manager at Royal London, considers holidays and Income protection .
New My Royal London adviser toolkit
We know the importance of fast, digital access. That’s why our online service, My Royal London, lets your clients manage their protection plan online.
Consumer Duty – is it a huge protection opportunity for adviser firms?
Shelley Read, Senior Intermediary Development and Technical Manager at Royal London, considers where advisers can find the protection opportunities within the Consumer Duty.
Acquisition of Responsible Life and Responsible Lending
Today, we announced that (subject to regulatory approval) we have wholly acquired later life lending and product specialists Responsible Life and Responsible Lending.
Making trusts even easier for you and your clients
Whether or not a client’s plan should be written in trust is something every adviser should consider. It could be argued that trusts are one of the most important financial planning tools at your fingertips.
The added value of advised protection
In the face of the rising cost of living, many people have changed their spending habits - at least a little - to help make their budgets stretch further.
Supporting your clients during a difficult time
In 2022 we paid 99.4% of all claims, helping 79,084 customers and their families at a difficult time. Our claims track record remains consistently strong, and it shows we’re committed to paying claims.
Royal London acquires Aegon UK’s individual protection book
Royal London has today announced it has reached an agreement with Aegon UK to acquire its individual protection line of business, subject to court approval.
Three things you might not know about Royal London protection
With a wide range of protection products that can be tailored around your clients’ needs and budgets, you can trust us to take care of your clients and their families.
How to place value on protection in tough times
It’s inevitable that during the current cost of living crisis, people will be keeping a watchful eye on their budgets - making savings where they can, so they can still afford the things that are important to them.
The impact of career changes on income protection
A job is rarely for life these days. On average, around 9% of people changed jobs each year between 2000 and 2018, ranging from a low of around 5.7% in 2010 to a high of around 10.9% in both 2017 and 2018.
The cost of living without protection
Britain’s cost-of-living crisis has hit us hard, and with ever increasing retail and energy prices affecting millions of households, protecting our income is now more important than ever.
Six ways our online service makes it easier to do business digitally
Digital trends have been accelerated by Covid-19, with remote working becoming the new way of life for many of us. That’s why we wanted to give you some practical hints and tips that we hope will be helpful in enabling you to do more digitally.
Five ways to help your clients stay financially resilient
With 95% of UK adults concerned about the rising cost of living* according to a recent Royal London study, are protection policies at risk of being scratched to save a few pounds?
Using a Whole of Life plan when inheritance tax planning
When thinking about inheritance tax planning one of the simplest things to do is put a whole of life plan in place to provide the funds to pay this after your client’s death.
Joint life policies and trusts – could you, should you?
Should you ever consider writing a joint life policy into trust? Is it even possible and if so, what are the benefits?
The advantages to adding indexation
By adding indexation you add the reassurance that should your clients need to make a claim in years to come, the pay-out is likely to better reflect the standard of living at that time. The value of the policy increases by a set amount over the duration of the plan which means that your clients should be in a better place to keep their family and lifestyle secure.
How family income benefit can provide an affordable protection solution
Protection doesn’t have to cost as much as they might think and there are a number of options available to keep the cost down. One of those options is family income benefit.
Additional anti money laundering (AML) checks
We’ve added some additional checks to further tighten our money laundering controls. These may impact your customers' plans, new applications or claim.